AI usually recommends other businesses for one of four reasons: it cannot read your website, your website is heavy and buries the point, nobody else on the internet mentions you, or your content answers questions your buyers are not asking. Each reason has a different fix, so the first step is working out which one is yours.
In my AI for Growth cohort, I ask everyone to run a simple test before we change anything: ask AI the question a buyer would ask and see who it names. When someone else comes up instead of you, it can feel personal, and it almost never is. It is usually one of the four reasons below.
Reason 1: AI cannot read your site
AI reads text. If your headline is inside a banner image, your services are listed in a graphic, or your best answer lives in a logo or a slide, AI cannot see any of it. To a human visitor the page looks complete, and to AI it is close to blank.
The fix: put the words that matter in real text on the page, starting with your headline and your first paragraph.
Reason 2: Your site is heavy
Some sites are slow, cluttered or built so the point sits far down the page under animations and long introductions. AI is looking for a clear answer near the top, and a page that builds slowly toward its point is harder to quote.
The fix: say plainly what you do, who it's for, where you work and the next step, all within the first 75 words of your homepage.
Reason 3: Nobody else mentions you
AI checks what you say about yourself against what other people say about you. It reads lists, reviews, press, blogs, Reddit and your Google Business Profile. If you only exist on your own website, AI has nothing to confirm you with, so it leans toward businesses that other sources talk about.
The fix: build mentions over time on the places AI reads, like reviews, local directories, guest posts and your Business Profile.
Reason 4: You answer questions nobody asks
Many websites talk about the business: our story, our values, our process. Buyers ask AI questions about their own problems. If your site never answers those questions directly, AI has nothing to lift into its reply.
The fix: turn your buyers' real questions into page sections and FAQs, with the question as the heading and a short answer right underneath.
Step by step: find your reason
- Ask your must-win question in a fresh chat in ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Google's AI answer.
- Read what it says about you. If it says it has no information, start with reasons 1 and 2. If it knows you and still names others, look at reason 3.
- Look at your homepage with the images turned off, or copy all the text into a plain document. Whatever is left is what AI sees.
- List the five questions customers ask you most, and check whether your site answers each one in plain words. Every missing answer points to reason 4.
- Pick one reason to fix first. Most businesses have one main reason, and trying to fix all four at once usually means none of them gets finished.
Frequently asked questions
Does paying for SEO fix this? Google still matters, and good SEO helps AI read your site. AI answers also depend on mentions elsewhere and on direct answers to real questions, so ranking well on Google does not guarantee AI will recommend you.
How long does it take for AI to recommend me after I fix my site? AI tools pick up changes at different speeds, and none of them promise a timeline. I check monthly with the same questions so the trend is easy to see.
Is this only for local businesses? No. Coaches, consultants, online educators and software founders all get compared by AI. Local businesses have the extra step of keeping a Google Business Profile current.
Watch me run the test
In this week's YouTube lesson, I ask ChatGPT who teaches AI to non-technical people and walk through what came back, including the part it got wrong about my own business. Watch it on the Build with AI Club YouTube channel If you're in San Francisco or want to audit online, my free AI 101 session is Wed Nov 18, 6 to 7 PM PT at SHACK15, and you can join the waitlist.